The Magic Behind Tiger Balm

A comparison of Tiger Balm and other topical pain relief products

Personal collection of pain relieving creams. / Photo by Body My Body.com

Personal collection of pain relieving creams. / Photo by Body My Body.com

I love Tiger Balm.  It is amazing.  Like Windex in My Big Fat Greek Wedding, I use Tiger Balm as a cure-all for muscle aches, sprains, strains, headaches, migraines, cough, and congestion in my head and lungs.

One time at the store I couldn’t find Tiger Balm and had to settle for Vicks VapoRub.  I have also had athletic trainers swear by Biofreeze.  Is there actually a difference between these products, or is it all in my head?  I did some research and put together a chart showing the active ingredients for comparison’s sake.  I chose popular brands that had products similar to my favorite–Tiger Balm Ultra (affiliate).  

 

Active Ingredients of Products Similar To Tiger Balm

Links embedded below are affiliate links.

ProductPictureMenthol (%)Camphor (%)Methyl
Salicylates (%)
Other
Tiger Balm Ultra [1]1111
Vicks VapoRub [2]2.64.8Eucalyptus Oil 1.2%
Biofreeze Professional Gel [3]5
Icy Hot [4]7.629
Ben Gay Ultra Strength [5]10430
Rock Sauce [6]]1020Capsaicin 0.002%
Aspercreme [7]Lidocaine 4%

Ingredients

Menthol

Menthol is used in a variety of substances for a variety of applications.  In the above products, it is probably used as a topical analgesic (basically a pain relieving cream applied to skin) or a cough suppressant [2].  It works here as a “counterirritant” which basically means your body feels the sensation of heat from the menthol as opposed to the pain nearby.  

Camphor

Camphor historically had a wide variety of uses like fireworks, mothballs, and as an ingredient for embalming ancient Egyptian mummies [8].  In 1982, the FDA set the final rule for the maximum allowable limit of camphor in consumer products to 11% due to poisonings from ingesting too much [9].  In the above products, camphor, like menthol, is seemingly used as a topical analgesic and a cough suppressant [2].  It works, like menthol, as a counterirritant.  

Methyl Salicylates

Methyl salicylates in the above products is likely used as a counterirritant [10].  Methyl salicylates are also the reason that Wint-O-Green Life Savers ® spark when you bite into them [11].  

Eucalyptus Oil

Eucalyptus oil, listed in Vick’s Vapor Rub, is used as a cough suppressant [2].  It may also have properties of a topical analgesic [12]. Interestingly, it can also be present in insect repellents.  

Capsaicin

Capsaicin is an active component in chili peppers and causes a burning sensation on our skin.  In Rock Sauce, it is likely used as a topical analgesic again.  Capsaicin may be used as a counterirritant here again, but it could also work by stimulating the release of a compound used in nerves communicating pain to the brain [13].  

Lidocaine

Lidocaine is different than the other active ingredients listed above.  Instead of working as a counterirritant, it works by blocking nerve signals in the skin.  It is considered a local anesthetic and has numbing properties [14].  

My Conclusions

My Tiger Balms are well worn because they go everywhere with me. / Photo by Body My Body.com

My Tiger Balms are well worn because they go everywhere with me. / Photo by Body My Body.com

All of the above products seem to work similarly by tricking your nerves into not sending pain signals to your brain.  I have used all of the products listed above except Rock Sauce (currently out of stock), which I didn’t know about until I started researching this article.  By far and away, I still love Tiger Balm the best.  I think Tiger Balm has the best texture, smell, and tingle.  Even if it isn’t as magical as I thought it was.


References:

[1]    “Tiger Balm Ultra.” Tiger Balm. Haw Par Corporation, 2014. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[2]    SnowDragon06, and NaomiDe. “VapoRub™ Topical Ointment.” Vicks®. Proctor & Gamble, 29 June 2012. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[3]    “Biofreeze Professional Gel.” Biofreeze. Performance Health, Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[4]    “ICY HOT BALM.” Icy Hot Balm. Chattem, Inc, 2014. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[5]    “Ultra Strength BENGAY® Cream.” BENGAY®. Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc. Web. 16 Sept. 2016.

[6]    “Bring the Fire.” RockTape. RockTape. Web. 06 Sept. 2016.

[7]    “Aspercreme Pain Relieving Cremes and Gels: Pain Relieving Creme with Lidocaine.” Aspercreme Pain Relieving Cremes and Gels: Pain Relieving Creme with Lidocaine. Chattem, Inc. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[8]    “Camphor.” Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[9]    Novitch, Mark, and Richard Schweiker. “Food and Drug Administration {Docket No. 80N-0227} New Drugs; Caphorated Oil Drug Products for Human Use Final Rule.” Federal Register 47.183 (1982): 41719. U. S. Food and Drug Administration. HeinOnline, 29 Oct. 2014. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[10]    “Methyl Salicylate-menthol Topical.” WebMD. WebMD. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[11]    “Why Do Wint-O-Green Life Savers Spark in the Dark?” HowStuffWorks. HowStuffWorks, 03 Nov. 2000. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[12]    Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database Consumer Version. “EUCALYPTUS.” WebMD. WebMD LLC. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[13]    Healthwise Staff. “Capsaicin.” WebMD. Ed. Adam Husney and Kathleen Romito. WebMD LLC, 23 Jan. 2014. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.

[14]    First Databank, Inc. “Lidocaine Topical.” WebMD. WebMD LLC. Web. 18 Aug. 2016.


 

Disclaimer
This website and information contained herein is meant for informational purposes only. You assume full responsibility and risk for the appropriate use of this information.

bodymybody

4 Comments

  1. Interesting article! Looking to buy some miracle balm, I notice that there is Tiger Balm and Tiger Balm Red. What’s the difference and do you recommend one over the other?

    • Tiger Balm Extra is the red one. It has 1% less menthol than Tiger Balm Ultra (the white one) and also has cinnamon and some other things that give it the red hue and more of a cinnamon-y smell. Some people like that smell, but I prefer the small of Tiger Balm Ultra. It is also a smidge more tingly (it could just be in by head though) and is white/clear ish so I don’t worry about it getting on my clothes as much. I have never had an issue with Tiger Balm Extra staining my clothes, but I just get nervous about it. So I prefer Tiger Balm Ultra (white), but if you want more of a cinnamon smell vs menthol smell, Extra (red) may be for you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *